A single Reddit thread has reignited one of the most emotionally charged education debates in America: Is the U.S. actually struggling with mass illiteracy, or are the numbers being twisted?
The answers, pulled from official data and blunt personal anecdotes, are far messier and more controversial than the viral headlines suggest, and yes, indeed, more than 1 in 5 US adults can’t read well enough, and it is costing trillions.
The Stat That Keeps Going Viral
View this post on Instagram
Social media posts often claim that “up to 28% of Americans can’t read.” On its face, that sounds catastrophic, especially when compared to countries like the UK, which is routinely labeled as having a 99% literacy rate.
Reddit users weren’t buying it.
Teachers, librarians, and data nerds flooded the comments, arguing that the claim is technically true, emotionally misleading, and politically explosive, all at the same time.
What the U.S. Actually Measures When It Says “Literacy”
Unlike basic yes-or-no literacy counts used in poorer countries, the U.S. relies on proficiency-based testing, mainly through assessments run by the National Center for Education Statistics and international frameworks tied to the OECD, as well as the National Literacy Institute’s latest data.
Here’s the breakdown most people never see:
That infamous 28% number does not mean Americans are staring blankly at street signs. It refers to adults scoring at the lowest proficiency levels, often still able to read short, simple texts but struggling with anything complex or multi-step.
Why Do People Say the Numbers “Feel Real”
What made the thread explode wasn’t the data; it was the lived experience.
- A librarian in a major East Coast city claimed adult illiteracy exceeds 50% locally, citing daily encounters with residents unable to complete basic reading tasks.
- Teachers reported graduating students who can decode words but cannot summarize, analyze, or follow written instructions.
- Healthcare workers noted they are trained to assume 6th-grade comprehension or lower when communicating with patients.
- Retail workers shared stories of customers unable to read part numbers, forms, or posted instructions.
These stories fueled a darker narrative: America may be technically literate, but practically struggling.
Immigration, Language, and a Statistical Gray Zone
Another flashpoint in the debate was language.
The U.S. tests English literacy. That means:
People argued that this alone inflates American “illiteracy” numbers when compared internationally.
A Real Decline, And Real Consequences
🇺🇸 In the United States, 54% of adults have a literacy below a 6th-grade level, 20% are below 5th-grade level, and 21% are illiterate.
Source: The National Literacy Institute
— World of Statistics (@stats_feed) February 1, 2025
Even defenders of U.S. education acknowledged one uncomfortable truth: scores are dropping.
Recent assessments show:
- The share of adults at the lowest literacy levels rose from 19% in 2017 to roughly 28% in newer data.
- The U.S. now ranks around 36th globally in literacy-related comparisons.
- Low literacy costs the U.S. economy an estimated $2.2 trillion per year, through lost productivity, higher healthcare costs, and reduced workforce participation.
Outlets like Newsweek have amplified these trends, helping push the issue back into public conversation.
Bottom Line
@usafacts.org Here are the 10 US states with the lowest literacy scores.📚Did any surprise you? Follow us for more data! #literacy #educationdata #USAFacts #BacktoSchool #datatalk ♬ original sound – USAFacts.org
The consensus landed somewhere deeply unsettling:
One comment summed it up brutally:
“People can read menus and Facebook posts. Ask them to read a lease, a ballot explanation, or a news article, and everything falls apart.”
That gap between basic literacy and functional understanding may explain why the statistic keeps resurfacing, why it feels true to so many people, and why it refuses to die – no matter how often experts say it’s being misused.
